Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company

Columbus, OH Finance & insuranceNAICS 524140

Self-funded health planPlan year 2025Renews January
22,817Participants-7% vs. prior year
$54.1MEst. pharmacy spend / yrParticipants × national avg.
Jan 2027Next renewalPlan year begins January 1
#1 of 22Finance & insurance in OHBy participants

Overview

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company sponsors a self-funded health plan that covered 22,817 participants in plan year 2025, down 7% from the prior year. The plan year starts in January. Alongside medical, its benefits filing reports life insurance, dental, vision, short-term disability, and more.

Plan type
ERISA welfare benefit plan, self-funded (benefits paid from employer assets or a trust)
Participants
22,817 · prior year 24,573
Plan year
Begins January 1 · next renewal January 2027
Health plans filed
Nationwide Insurance Companies & Affiliates Employee Assistance Plan, plan 508 (22,817 participants); NIC & Affiliates Health Reimbursement Account Plan for Retirees & Ltd Recipients, plan 526 (4,593 participants); Nationwide Medical Flexible Spending Account Plan, plan 506 (1,535 participants)
MedicalLife insuranceDentalVisionShort-term disabilityLong-term disabilitySeveranceDeath benefitsOther welfare benefits

Insurance carriers

Insured coverage reported on Schedule A. Self-funded medical claims aren't reported there.

CarrierCoverageCoveredPremiumBroker comp
Nationwide Life Insurance CompanyMedical, Life, Accidental Death & Dismemberment31,833$22.2M—
Eyemed Vision CareVision34,805$3.2M—
Sierra Health and Life Insurance Company, Inc.Medical4,507$2.7M—
Kaiser Foundation Health Plans, Inc.Medical, HMO299$2.7M—
Banner Health and Aetna HealthMedical, HMO257$2.0M—
Aetna Life Insurance Company & AffiliatesDental, HMO1,497$471K—
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Colorado, Inc.Medical, HMO83$460K—
Cigna Health & Life Insurance Company & AffiliatesDental, HMO1,381$364K—
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Mid-Atlantic States, Inc.Medical, HMO49$273K—
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Georgia, Inc.Medical, HMO54$268K—
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the NorthwestMedical, HMO26$158K—

Pharmacy benefit estimate

StreamRX estimate for a plan this size. Not based on this plan's claims.

$54.1M/ year

Estimated prescription spend: 22,817 participants × $2,371 national average per member. Usually higher once dependents are counted.

$1.4M–$3.5M/ year

Typical savings opportunity found in independent reviews of plans this size.

Brands with a generic available$411K–$1.0M
Lower-cost therapeutic alternatives$601K–$1.3M
Generic pricing vs. actual cost$260K–$779K
PBM contract terms$135K–$406K
The DOL's PBM fee disclosure rule first applies to this plan for the plan year beginning January 2028: semiannual PBM compensation reports and an annual audit right.

Form 5500 filing details

Filing
Form 5500 with Schedule A, plan year 2025
Plan sponsor
Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company
Sponsor EIN
31-4177100
Plan numbers
508, 526, 506
Filed with
U.S. Department of Labor (EBSA) via EFAST2

Verify this filing: search EIN 31-4177100 in the Department of Labor's EFAST2 Form 5500 search.

Retirement plan

Plan
Nationwide Savings Plan
Type
401(k) plan
Participants
40,207

About this data

Source: Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company's Form 5500 filing for plan year 2025 and its Schedule A insurance reports, published by the U.S. Department of Labor. "Self-funded" means the filing reports benefits paid from employer assets or a trust, with no medical insurance contract or with a stop-loss contract. Pharmacy figures are StreamRX estimates based on national averages. StreamRX is not affiliated with Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company.

Request a correction · Methodology